The Abandonment of the West

February 10, 2020
The once influential notion of the United States as the champion of Western civilization has lapsed, leaving Euro-American relations rudderless, according to this ruminative history. Kimmage (In History’s Grip), a history professor at Catholic University of America and former State Department planner, traces the doctrine that Europe and America belonged to a unified Western culture of liberty, law, and democracy to 20th-century academics and foreign-policy intellectuals; this ideology, he notes, birthed Western Civilization college courses and justified America’s intervention in Europe’s battle against Nazi Germany and Cold War confrontation with communism. It was undermined, he argues, by the Left’s critique of Western racism and imperialism, the Right’s critique of Western liberalism’s decadence and godlessness, and the Third World’s resentment of Western colonialism. Since 1989, Kimmage notes, presidents have dropped talk of defending Western civilization, and, more recently, President Trump has voiced a populist contempt for the whole project of Euro-American cooperation. Kimmage’s erudite and far-ranging discussion of debates over Western-ness highlights the perspectives of critics like James Baldwin, W.E.B. DuBois, and Edward Said, but his weak argument for reviving a Euro-American alliance relies on vague concerns about challenges from Russia and China. Contrary to the author’s intentions, some readers will leave this tepid study feeling that the rhetoric of Western solidarity is no longer relevant.

February 14, 2020

The West as an idea is an intriguing concept, and one that has generated much literature over the years. Kimmage's (history, Catholic Univ. of America; The Conservative Turn) latest book stands apart because of its historical and philosophical treatment of what Western culture means to contemporary Americans. Going back to the late 19th century, Kimmage traces the various theories of international relations, beginning with Woodrow Wilson's internationalism, and examines the evolution of America's engagement with the rest of the world during the course of the 20th century. Kimmage points out that, in our present century, the traditional view of Western dominance is now being challenged by the rise of China and Russia, and that we should reconsider the mindset that Western culture is superior to others. VERDICT This is an exceedingly important book and certainly one that would benefit all American readers who wonder how we arrived at our current status in an increasingly interconnected world. Highly recommended for all collections.--Ed Goedeken, Iowa State Univ. Lib., Ames

Copyright 2020 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.