Stalin
New Biography of a Dictator
کتاب های مرتبط
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی
April 1, 2015
Khlevniuk (Master of the House: Stalin and His Inner Circle, 2008, etc.) delves into the existing body of work surrounding Stalin's life and career to separate fact from fiction, and he crafts a complete picture of a complex man. The author opens on the final hours of Joseph Stalin's life. From there, he bounces between a chronological retelling of the dictator's rise to power and a detailed examination of the man on his deathbed. It's an interesting choice that lends an element of retrospection from the very beginning, as readers attempt to find linkages between the mythic Stalin in his later years and the young Georgian student Ioseb Jughashvili. Khlevniuk carefully dismantles the many theories and fictions that surround the life of Stalin, a helpful touch given the long-standing lack of official documentation from the Soviet era. In place of speculation, the author offers readers a portrait of Stalin's rise to and stranglehold on power, grounded in the leader's paranoia, opportunism, and willingness to rewrite even his own recent history. Khlevniuk offers deep analysis of the political situation in Russia at various key moments in Stalin's career, which is useful but at times detailed to the point of distraction. Although the author does not give Stalin the benefit of the doubt when it comes to culpability for the many atrocities that took place during his reign, he doesn't make Stalin an otherworldly monster. Instead, Khlevniuk's narrative requires readers to hold in mind the many seemingly contradictory facts of his subject's life at once. A former seminary student, an ambitious revolutionary, a loving father, and a dictator responsible for the deaths of millions: Stalin is all of these, and Khlevniuk makes room for them all. An ambitious yet manageable biography of Stalin, this book sheds new light on its subject for amateur historians and experts alike.
April 15, 2015
Russia has been ruled by a long list of tyrants. Khlevniuk (History of the Gulag), a senior research fellow at several Russian institutes including the State Archive of the Russian Federation, places Joseph Stalin (1878-1953) if not first, certainly among the top, of this ignominious list. Stalin was responsible for the suffering and death of millions during his 24-year reign. His rule of the Soviet Union was empowered by paranoia, spying, and denunciation from the highest levels of the Kremlin to the lives of everyday citizens. Extensively footnoted with newly accessible sources from Russian state archives, Khlevniuk's work convincingly proves that the policies of terror, assassination, state-sponsored famine, and the Gulag were conceived by Stalin and carried out with his full knowledge and approval. Although Stephen Kotkin's Stalin: Paradoxes of Power 1878-1928 has more historical context, Khlevniuk meticulously charts, in one volume, Stalin's entire life from childhood poverty through his rise to power and years of rule, with a dramatic recounting of the last few days of the despot's experience. VERDICT Readers with an interest in Soviet history, and those who can't wait for the next two volumes of Kotkin's Stalin, will appreciate this well-documented portrayal of a man whose despotic rule reverberates in Russia to this day.--Laurie Unger Skinner, Coll. of Lake County, Waukegan, IL
Copyright 2015 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
دیدگاه کاربران