Beware That Girl

February 29, 2016
Kate O’Brian is a good liar when she has to be, and because of her violent past, that’s most of the time. She’s also good at making “demented rich girls” love her, which is how she goes from sleeping in a storeroom under a Chinatown market to sharing Olivia Sumner’s penthouse apartment during the girls’ senior year at New York City’s posh Waverly School. Toten (The Unlikely Hero of Room 13B) switches between Kate’s first-person account and a third-person look at Olivia, who has secrets of her own. The other plot engine is charismatic Waverly fund-raiser Mark Redkin, who is working on bedding most of the staff and some of the seniors. When Olivia’s turn comes, readers realize that he is far worse than just a hound. As the title suggests, the book combines a Gossip Girl milieu with the unsettled psychological terrain of Gone Girl. But while Kate is a strong character and there is no shortage of suspense, Toten’s desire to keep readers guessing results in a confusing and rushed climax. Ages 14–up. Agent: Marie Campbell, Transatlantic Literary Agency.

March 15, 2016
Predators become prey in this private school novel. Kate O'Brien is the new scholarship student at Waverly Academy in New York City, but she's also a seasoned con artist armed with the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, and she intends to do anything and use anyone in order to get away from her past and into Yale. Kate targets Olivia Sumner in order to get out of poverty and in with the popular girls, but she finds her cold calculations tempered by friendship. Kate's first-person narration proudly details her manipulative methods (with flashbacks to a traumatic childhood that offers motive), while the third-person voice in Olivia's chapters goes from detached to disjointed as she pops Ativan like Altoids but slowly spills her secrets. Kate and Olivia, both white, think they can swim with the sharks, yet both are outclassed when a man complicates matters, and only Kate can see the sociopath beneath the suave charm. Shallowly drawn schoolmates are also saddled with enough psychological issues to fill Kate's beloved DSM but otherwise fulfill rich-girl, private school stereotypes and provide background color. Toten's use of sexual predation and parental abuse as plot devices is problematic, but she also delivers a social-climbing satire with a ridiculous resolution, making for a reading experience that feels simultaneously riveting and like rubbernecking. A tense teen thriller that is half mind-game, half misery lit--call it 50 Shades of Grey Area. (Thriller. 14-18)

COPYRIGHT(2016) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

May 1, 2016

Gr 10 Up-Street smart and already world-weary, 17-year-old Kate is an admitted liar. She lies with the goal of one day attending Yale University, her dream school. As a new scholarship student at the prestigious Waverly School in New York, she relies heavily on her smarts, good looks, and experience to get by. Kate searches for a target, someone to befriend who has influence and money. She spots Olivia, a beautiful and rich girl who missed a year of school because of a mystery illness. Kate moves into Olivia's absent father's penthouse, with only a housekeeper as parental guidance. The friendship blossoms, until a mysterious man, Mark Redkin, enters their lives. The handsome Mark charms Olivia, but Kate senses that there is something terribly wrong. She discovers that he is a dangerous psychopath with a past as dark and carefully concealed as Kate's and Olivia's. Alternating chapters between the two teens keep the story fresh and make readers feel privy to secrets. Kate's tragic history is revealed with flashbacks. The plot develops at a steady pace until the game being played among all three characters finally blows up with tragedy and murder. In this book for older teens, the author skillfully reveals gritty and tantalizing details in meager bites, keeping readers captivated.

Copyright 2016 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

May 1, 2016
Grades 9-12 Kate O'Brien has had her sights set on Yale since she was 10. Using street and book smarts and more than a few lies, she's landed a scholarship for her senior year at New York City's prestigious Waverly School, which should give her enough clout during the admissions process. Connections can't hurt either, so she befriends Olivia, whose family has attended Yale for generations. Chapters switch between the girls' perspectives, revealing that both have secret histories and agendas for pursuing a friendship with one another. The arrival of gorgeous Mr. Redkin at Waverly sets off an alarm in Kate's head, but Olivia falls victim to his predatory charm. Toten moves her psychological thriller forward at a quiet pace, building tension as she teases out character motivations and unsavory secrets. The private school setting, beautiful blondes in designer fashions, and air of mystery make this ideal for fans of E. Lockhart's We Were Liars (2014). Some may find the story's final twist unconvincing, but many will revel in the insidious masquerade.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2016, American Library Association.)