Famous Phonies

January 1, 2015

Gr 4-9-Think Confucius was a wise old man revered in his lifetime? Under the impression that George Washington was a great hero? Believe that Pythagoras came up with a theorem that changed mathematics forever? Prepare to be disillusioned as independent historian DuMont debunks many of history's legends, both those who really existed and some who never did. The book's lively, breezy style often descends to the snarky and sarcastic and may spark a healthy skepticism about textbook history. A number of pop culture references (Bedazzler, the Angry Birds) have current appeal but will quickly date the text. DuMont lists sources for each chapter, most of which are reliable, even excellent. However, there are no in-text citations, which makes corroboration problematic and should leave readers with at least a modicum of doubt about this version of history. Some popular websites, such as BrainyQuotes.com and John Green's short, flashy "Crash Course" YouTube videos, are questionable; students would be better served if they had been directed to these as entertaining sidelights rather than as reference sources. A fun read, but unsuitable for research or reports.-Katherine Koenig, The Ellis School, PA

Copyright 2015 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.