A Different Mirror

Takaki's overview of the role of minorities in America's history--native, immigrant, racial, national, ethnic, and religious--clearly takes their side and sympathizes with their often appalling treatment but saves overt polemic for the conclusion. Peter Berkrot's narration, fittingly, adopts a tone of mostly understated sympathy. Quotations often suggest an accent or dialect--Hispanic, Southern, Irish, for example--a tactic that adds warmth and color but manages to skirt stereotyping by its subtlety. Berkrot's voice is a bit astringent but serviceable; his reading well paced, eloquent, and clear; his tone and expression are well matched to the text. Barring a few high-profile mispronunciations ("epi-stemology"), he gives a professional but personable reading of a history more Americans should know. W.M. (c) AudioFile 2011, Portland, Maine