Culloden

September 5, 2016
British military historian Royle (Crimea: The Great Crimean War, 1854–1856) explores how the 1746 Battle of Culloden destroyed Bonnie Prince Charlie’s dreams of a Stuart restoration but prepared the British army for subsequent successes in implementing Britain’s imperial ambitions. Inspired by lingering controversy over the heavily mythologized Scottish battleground, Royle places the battle in the context of the English/Protestant/Hanoverian rebuffing of French/Catholic/Jacobite rebellion. His main purpose is addressing Britain’s significant military achievements over the course of the post-Culloden generation. Rather than presenting a litany of battles, Royle intersperses clear logistical and strategic discussions with biographical sketches to flesh out the redcoats’ four-decade-long expansion around the globe. British opponents in North America, the Caribbean, and India receive due attention and respect, but the work persists as a largely appreciative look at the British Army. Royle acknowledges that British soldiers committed acts of brutality and terror in multiple locations, but also puts these horrific events into historical context. In addition, he provides lucid explanations of how poor decisions
(initially by the British), bad luck, and staff disagreements affected the outcome of each major battle in this period for either side. Culloden’s importance to Scotland’s fortunes has never been doubted; Royle now demonstrates that its relevance to decades of British global supremacy cannot be questioned.

Starred review from October 1, 2016

The Battle of Culloden in 1746 was the last major struggle fought on British ground, and its tragic consequences for the French-supported Jacobites are frequently surrounded by myth. In his most recent work, military historian Royle (The Road to Bosworth Field) dispels the legends, and persuasively argues that Culloden was the beginning of a greater campaign by the British to eliminate the threat of imminent French invasion and weaken the possibility of future Catholic interference in British affairs. Royle contends that, having contained these threats, Britain could then focus on expanding its global influence. Many of the British officers who fought at Culloden subsequently used the experience to eliminate the French presence in British North America, the Caribbean, and India, thus sowing the seeds of the British Empire. Brilliant and engaging, Royle places Culloden and its aftermath into its true military and social context. The narrative is alive with a passion for the subject. VERDICT A marvelous introduction to Culloden for a wide range of readers, this book deserves a place in all types of library collections.--Penelope J.M. Klein, Fayetteville, NY

Copyright 2016 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.