Imperial Ambitions

October 3, 2005
The infuriating, indispensable dean of American dissidents returns with this new collection of interviews with long-time amanuensis Barsamian. In these wide-ranging conversations, linguist and philosopher Chomsky, author of Hegemony or Survival, applies his usual left-wing critique of U.S. foreign policy to recent developments in Iraq, but also revisits American infamies stretching back to the Kosovo conflict, the Vietnam War and even the Mexican War while weighing in on domestic issues like Social Security privatization, health insurance and the rise of the Religious Right. His caustic denunciations of American "war crimes" -comparisons to Nazi Germany are never far from hand-serve up plenty of red meat for his legions of fans on the disaffected left, but the discursive, unsystematic format is not the best introduction for readers unfamiliar with his nonconformist views. One wishes Chomsky would find a more challenging interlocutor than the always-reverent Barsamian to sharpen up his thinking. His estimate of the coherence and vigor of the American imperial project seems overwrought. His analysis of the role of oil politics in the Iraq war is murky. And his portrait of the media as a quasi-Orwellian "propaganda" system brainwashing the population on behalf of the ruling elite smacks of naive populism. Still, it's hard to dismiss Chomsky's indictment of the damage done by U.S. policies abroad, his scornful dissection of the lies and hypocrisies of those who defend them, his insistence that wealth and class interests dominate American politics, or his uncompromising attack on the thoughtless presumption of America's right to impose its will by force on other countries. A sardonic, meticulous and always bracing critic of the powers that be, Chomsky remains a must-read for any thoughtful citizen.

One of the most important and controversial linguists of the last century, Chomsky is better known to the public for his controversial, iconoclastic politics. Here he discusses his views of the post-9/11 world with David Barsamian, host of the syndicated program "Alternative Radio." Are there hidden agendas in officialdom? Are Americans in danger of losing their liberties? Are protective measures against terrorism ineffective? Does the power elite mercilessly bully the Third World? Chomsky thinks so. Barsamian never challenges his guest's opinions and questionable facts, convinced, it seems, of Chomsky's grasp of recent history. Charlie Rose, where are you when we need you? Y.R. (c) AudioFile 2006, Portland, Maine