How the Dead Speak

Starred review from October 14, 2019
In Edgar-finalist McDermid’s riveting 11th Tony Hill and Carol Jordan novel (after 2017’s Insidious Intent), developers digging on the grounds of the shuttered Order of the Blessed Pearl convent, near Bradfield, England, uncover more than 30 children’s skeletons, triggering an investigation by the regional major incident team. With Carol off the force and afflicted with PTSD, and Tony in prison for manslaughter, the team members suffer under the new leadership of Detective Chief Inspector Rutherford, who’s hostile toward them. The stakes rise after the discovery of the murdered bodies of young men in a different area of the convent grounds. Interviews with an elderly retired priest, Fr. Michael Keenan, and Mother Benedict, who ran the convent, reveal a disturbing pattern of abuse at the hands of the nuns. Carol is lured out of isolation by a defense attorney, who persuades her to sign on to a new organization that helps wrongly convicted felons find justice. Series fans will be pleased to see Tony and Carol reunite after a long separation, despite the uncertainty of their complicated relationship’s future. McDermid is writing at the top of her game. Agent: Jane Gregory, David Higham Assoc.

Narrator Saul Reichlin returns to deliver the next phase in the challenging lives of the many characters in McDermid's Tony Hill/Carol Jordan series. Reichlin successfully differentiates men and women of differing ages and backgrounds. With Hill and Jordan sidelined, the rebuilt REMIT team is drawn into unraveling the mystery of the bones of 40 girls who are buried at the former site of a Catholic convent and the nearby discovery of the remains of eight young men. Newcomers will find enough backstory to follow the complex relationships. Listeners will step into an engaging story with well-performed characters, dialogue, and plot and will be left with cliff-hangers in anticipation of the next installment. E.Q. � AudioFile 2020, Portland, Maine