Room with a Pew

July 15, 2012
In their latest dispatches from abroad, Starks and Murcutt (Along the River that Flows Uphill: From the Orinoco to the Amazon, 2009, etc.) take readers on a pilgrimage to seven monasteries across Spain. The authors' use of immersion journalism provides unique insight into the inner sanctum of the monasteries, as they describe glimpses of a variety of treasures, including relics, artifacts and art. Better still is their shared insight into the psychology behind a life dedicated to God. Upon entering one monastery's refectory, the writers wondered, "Could I eat here? Three times a day in silence? With the same group of people? For fifty years or more?" These questions, while rhetorical for the authors, undoubtedly had real-world ramifications for those who decided to engage in the monastic life. Yet when one monk notes the dearth of new recruits, readers may wonder if the answers to the aforementioned questions have often been a negative, if the monastic life is an endangered species soon to be another casualty of the modern world. While the book begins as a grand parade across Spain, it soon takes on characteristics of a forced march in which the primary difference among the monasteries are the people within their walls. Early on, Starks and Murcutt describe one monastery as "quiet and peaceful with an unhurried pace"--a good description for this book. There is little agency here, and while the authors faithfully report their trip, faith itself plays a minor role. Lighthearted and occasionally humorous, but not fully engaging.

COPYRIGHT(2012) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

November 15, 2012

Starks and Murcutt (coauthors, Along the River That Flows Uphill: From the Orinoco to the Amazon) chronicle their journey across Spain by way of its monasteries. This is not a guidebook to monastery hotels in Spain; despite a small section on how to plan a trip, any information about location, price, availability, and quality is only incidental to the narrative. Instead, its appeal is as a window into a centuries-old way of life, a living piece of history. Christian readers interested in following in the authors' footsteps will be disappointed. Not religious, Starks and Murcutt are disinterested in, and sometimes even mildly disdainful of, the spiritual significance of these sites and their tone may be offensive to readers of faith. Still, their wry sense of humor will hold readers' interest in a narrative without much action. VERDICT This book will appeal to readers of Spanish or Roman Catholic history more than to travelers or devout Christians. With few other titles on this specific topic published in the last several years, it is worth consideration where such subjects are popular.--Audrey Barbakoff, Kitsap Regional Lib., Bainbridge Island, WA

Copyright 2012 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.