The Key to Every Thing

April 1, 2018

Gr 4-6-This heartfelt and often sad story follows the coming-of-age of 11-year-old Tash. Uncle Kevin, her legal guardian, is off on a monthlong trip to New Zealand and Tash is forced to spend the summer in a camp. She's initially resistant and takes out her anger on Uncle Kevin and Cap'n Jackie, her elderly and curmudgeonly next-door neighbor with whom she shares a deep bond. Upon returning from camp, Tash is distressed to find that Cap'n Jackie is gone-she's in a rehab facility after breaking her hip. This is a simple tale about loving and letting go, showing deep levels of understanding, forgiveness, and love between a close-knit family defined on its own terms. Schmatz takes the axiom of "show, not tell" seriously in the quest to avoid defining people by their histories and legal relationships; as the story unfolds these things slowly become clear. After an opening section written through letters and emails, the pacing steadies, unfolding Tash's realistic character growth through single-scene, short chapters. VERDICT An emotional read likely to appeal to sensitive middle grade souls, affirming with positive normalcy the familial roles of lesbian and gay adults.-Rhona Campbell, Georgetown Day School, Washington, DC

Copyright 2018 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

March 15, 2018
Traumatized by past neglect at the hands of an alcoholic parent, an "almost-sixth-grader" faces her phobia of being alone after her elderly friend is injured.Tash resents that she has to go to camp while her loving great-uncle and custodian, Kevin, goes to New Zealand. She'd rather stay with her whimsical elderly neighbor, Cap'n Jackie, and hear her stories. Isolated by agoraphobia and grief, Cap'n Jackie retreats into a fantasy while Tash is away: An old key summons a magical dragon/dolphin and the spirits of her cat, Mulligan, and her partner, Vanessa. Tash had angrily thrown the key at Cap'n Jackie before leaving, a gesture with greater consequences than she realizes. While Tash is at camp, the friends' brief handwritten correspondence reveals their mutual quick tempers as well as their bond. When Tash returns, she learns that Cap'n Jackie has been admitted to a rehab facility after breaking her hip--and, it seems, her spirit. Tash vows to find the key and make amends, not realizing that her solo mission is preparing her for being alone in a different way. (Readers, however, may notice some heavy foreshadowing.) Though her affection for Tash is clear, Cap'n Jackie herself is little more than a lonely old person--feistiness notwithstanding--whose ultimate function is to help Tash learn a life lesson or two. But Tash's volatile emotions and Kevin's gentle steadiness ring true, adding dimension to the tear-jerking trope. The book seems to adhere to the white default.A bittersweet but hopeful take on loss, trauma, and the many meanings of family. (Fiction. 9-12)

COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

June 4, 2018
In this middle-grade drama, 11-year-old Tash returns home from summer camp to discover that Cap’n Jackie, the elderly next-door neighbor who’s helped raise her, has been admitted to a rehab facility following an accident. Still unsettled from a fight the two had before she left for camp, Tash can’t wait to make amends and have everything go back to normal. What will she do without her friend’s cookies, hugs, and fanciful stories? Unfortunately, Cap’n Jackie is unresponsive after undergoing hip surgery, and Tash must find a way to break through to her. She wonders if the magical key Cap’n Jackie once gave her might help. Schmatz (Lizard Radio) captures the uncertainty and turbulent emotions of a girl struggling with change and loss while examining the value of found family. Schmatz’s novel is heartfelt, but the letters and memories that depict Tash’s relationship with Cap’n Jackie fail to fully explore the true strength of their bond and its impact upon the story. Ages 8–12. Agent: David Bennett, Transatlantic Literary Agency.

Starred review from April 15, 2018
Grades 4-6 *Starred Review* Eleven-year-old Tash is furious that Kevin, her uncle and guardian, has arranged for her to spend a month at summer camp, and has raged at her feisty, imaginative, beloved neighbor, Cap'n Jackie, calling her a crazy old lady for backing up Kevin's decision. Four weeks later, Tash returns home in a happier frame of mind, only to find that Cap'n Jackie has a broken hip. In the rehab facility, Tash finds her old friend silent and unresponsive, despite attempts to reach her through memories of magical times they have shared. A letter from Jackie, delivered after her death, helps Tash let go of regrets, mourn her loss, and keep going. Early in the book, letters to and from camp offer lively introductions to the characters. Schmatz vividly portrays Tash and Jackie, each as stubborn, quick-tempered, and fearful at heart as the other. Steadfast and dependable, Kevin serves as a foil for both. The novel will take some readers outside their comfort zones, into the sometimes scary arena of health care facilities and the never-easy subject of death. But the strong presentation of Tash's viewpoint is reassuring, and so is the straightforward depiction of her discomfort, anger, jealousy, remorse, reconciliation, and sadness. A simply written, emotionally resonant narrative.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2018, American Library Association.)