Soldier's Game

February 20, 2012
Killgore weaves a historical story into the framework of a contemporary one about 11-year-old Ross, who is sick of being taunted for his clumsiness, which often contributes to his football (soccer) team's lackluster performances. When Ross's grandmother unearths a box containing his great-grandfather Jack Jordan's photos, newspaper articles, and memorabilia in the attic, Ross becomes inspired by his grandfather's passionate life. Jack played for Ross's favorite team, the Heart of Midlothian, which formed a club of players and fans to fight in the army under Sir George McCrae during WWI. Wearing Jack's old boots, Ross dreams of the glory of being at Tynecastle stadium, but his grandmother tells him the other side of the story of the 16th Royal Scots or "Hearts Battalion," a story of the hardships of life in the trenches of Edinburgh. While the two narrative strands each offer a strong central character, their stories feel only tangentially connected, rather than forming a satisfying cohesive thread. Readers may struggle to be fully invested in the sweet but slender scenario. Ages 9âup.