
Clancy of the Undertow
کتاب های مرتبط
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی

October 1, 2016
An Australian teen copes with poverty and family problems as she fumbles toward acceptance of her lesbianism.Clancy is a foulmouthed, snarky, scrawny 16-year-old. Her first-person narration is peppered with slang, her conversations with older brother Angus humorously vulgar. Curries first teen title covers a week in Clancys life and veers from humor to drama and back again (several times), packing in what might feel like a few too many quirky characters and life-changing events. What with her fathers possible involvement in a fatal car crash, her older brothers obsession with cryptids, a new friends unfortunate experience of being severely bullied, and her secret crushs sudden interest, Clancy is off-balance and overwhelmed. Her self-sabotaging behavior and corrosive humor will likely be familiar to many teens, but sorting through unfamiliar words and cultural references takes work and may discourage some potential readers. Most of the supporting characters are apparently white, but Clancy, her mom, and her siblings are part-Aboriginal. She describes their skin as yellowy-brown which she attributes to her Mums dads dad. Aside from that single reference, however, race isnt mentioned, leaving readers to infer for themselves how much the familys struggles are related to prejudice. Funny, gritty, absorbing, and occasionally depressing, this is an intriguing if occasionally melodramatic glimpse of a young Australian womans coming-of-age. (Fiction. 14-18)
COPYRIGHT(2016) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

December 1, 2016
Gr 9 Up-This novel begins with a crisis: Clancy's father has been involved in a horrific car accident in which two local teens have been killed. Readers are immediately thrust into the center of a family and community drama that results in Clancy feeling even more ostracized and detached from her peers than she evidently already was. With an older brother who is a conspiracy theorist, a father with an undesirable past, an active membership in the nerdy Nature Club, and a major crush on the local bad girl, Clancy is a bit of a misfit. When the opportunity appears to make an unexpected friend, newcomer Nancy, in Nature Club, Clancy nearly blows it for the chance to connect with her crush, Sasha. After then being rejected by Sasha, Clancy spirals into despair and confusion, but her brother and a few other reliable friends bring her back from the brink thanks to their acceptance of who she really is. A near-death experience, plus the unexpected reversals of fortune, makes for a high-impact ending. Some American students may be initially thrown off by the Australian cultural references and slang. In addition, a few of the secondary characters are not fully developed, and even Clancy's identity feels hard to grasp at times (perhaps deliberately so). VERDICT A tense depiction of family secrets and personal acceptance, this title should appeal to readers who liked Julie Anne Peters's Far from Xanadu.-Nora G. Murphy, Flintridge Sacred Heart Academy, LaCanada-Flintridge, CA
Copyright 2016 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
دیدگاه کاربران