Edward's Eyes

Starred review from September 10, 2007
Ventimiglia's soft voice and smooth delivery capture all the notes of fun, sadness and eventually, emergent hope that fill MacLachlan's novel about the powerful bonds of a family's love. Through the flashback memories of Jake, listeners meet Jake's younger brother, the strikingly blue-eyed Edward, a standout in their ever-expanding family for his baseball pitching prowess, his good humor and his ability to “see” signs that other people often miss. Listeners will discern early on that something must have happened to Edward, as Jake's reverent narration—which sometimes sounds wise beyond his years—creates a portrait of a boy who seems to be somewhere else. As the story unfurls, listeners learn Edward's heartbreaking fate and how his family copes. Having tissues on hand for some of the latter chapters may be a good idea, though the tale closes on an uplifting note. Ages 8-up.

June 1, 2008
Gr 4-6-When Jake's parents have a new baby, the three-year-old is captivated. It's clear that Edward is special. He is unusually insightful, teaches himself to throw a perfect knuckleball, and knows that baby number six is going to be a girl. The new baby, he proclaims, will be named Sabine and they will celebrate her birth with fireworks. Patricia McLachlan's tale (Atheneum, 2007) is told through Jake's eyes in a series of memories. After Edward is killed in a biking accident, his parents announce that they have donated his organs and corneas. At first Jake is devastated, but the donation of the corneas to a young baseball player ultimately helps the boy find solace and move on. Milo Ventimiglia's narration reflects the gentle tone of the story and will capture the hearts of listeners.Deanna Romriell, Salt Lake City Public Library, UT

Copyright 2008 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.