Judy, Prisoner of War

February 1, 2018

Gr 2-5-Calkhoven has splendidly added a fictional war narrative to a factual cast of characters. Readers learn about the life of Judy, an English Pointer born in pre-WWII China. Through the chapters, Judy gets in all sorts of adventures and makes friends and foes. She is adopted by The Royal Navy initially to be a hunting dog; but after proving to be not-so-skilled at hunting, she shines as a watchdog for the ship and its men. As WWII begins, the tone becomes more serious as Judy and her companions weather the trials and tribulations throughout the war. Judy truly illustrates the "man's best friend" role and brings some lightheartedness to an otherwise serious time in history. VERDICT While Calkhoven adeptly synthesizes this adult-themed content for children, some of the details about war make this more suitable for upper elementary readers.-David Roberts, Salem Public Library, OH

Copyright 2018 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

February 1, 2018
If dogs could talk, World War II veteran Judy might have described her adventures the same way Calkhoven does.Judy was an English pointer who was born in Shanghai in 1936. During peacetime, she was adopted by the crew of a British gunboat, the Gnat, and later transferred to the HMS Grasshopper. This latter boat, with civilian refugees onboard, was attacked by the Japanese and sunk in February 1942. The survivors, including Judy, took refuge on an island but were captured by the Japanese. Judy and her POW caretakers spent the rest of the war in prison camps where brutal treatment, little food, and a high mortality rate were the norm. Judy, while staying away from and defying Japanese guards, surreptitiously gathered food for the starving men and also helped morale by performing tricks she was taught by her human friend Frank Williams. After the war, Frank and Judy returned to England, but later they worked in Britain's African colonies, where (she reports) she was euthanized at the age of 14. Judy's fictionalized story is a remarkable tale of loyalty and the bond that can develop between dogs and people, describing but not focusing on the brutality of war. The young readers' edition of Robert Weintraub's No Better Friend (2016), for a slightly older audience, presents Judy's story with much more detail, but this effort is just right for emergent readers.Best for young dog lovers. (Historical fiction. 8-11)

COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.