The Queen's Secret

March 1, 2019
The second book in the Rose Legacy series presents new challenges for human Anthea and stallion Florian (and readers too).Anthea, her uncle Andrew, cousin Jilly, and others at Last Farm are now--along with their horses (with whom they communicate telepathically)--working for the Crown of Coronam as messengers. It's part of a campaign by Queen Josephine to get the rest of the kingdom (king included) past the idea, rooted in legend, that horses brought a terrible plague to Coronam ages ago and so are to be feared and exterminated. Suffering terribly from middle-book syndrome, this story throws out bits of plot, eschewing character development, congruity, and even, at times, plausibility. The one comprehensible thread is that there's a contagious disease spreading around the countryside, and people are beginning to blame the horses again. An all-woman team of scientists arrives at Last Farm to work on finding a cure. (Despite this gesture, gender stereotypes persist: Jilly is tediously interested in form-fitted clothes, and Anthea sees tears as a weakness.) There are twinges of war rumors with a not-nice country called Kronenhofer, some unsubtle nudges regarding Anthea's traitor of a mother, and a plodding subplot about how Anthea's friend Finn is the rightful king. Settings are numerous and interchangeable (as are most of the characters), and the saccharine "Beloved"-bestrewn telepathic addresses between Anthea and Florian have definitely reached the eye-roll stage.A tedious, confusing setup for Book 3. Disappointing. (Fantasy. 10-14)

COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

April 15, 2019
Grades 3-6 Anthea and her beloved family and friends and horses are struggling to be of use to the kingdom, which hates and mistrusts them. Then an epidemic breaks out, and when they try to deliver medicine to help, they're chased away from the sickened and frightened villagers. To top it all off, Anthea has a sick feeling that her mother, an enemy and spy of the highest order, has something to do with it. This second volume in the Rose Legacy trilogy is, in many ways, even better than the first. Since she isn't tasked with setting up all the rules and lore of the world, George charges right into the story, and the pacing doesn't let up for one instant. The focused, nuanced details keep the story appealingly unpredictable. This work does everything that's best about middle books: it's fast-paced, bridging between the expository first book and roaring finale. Fans of war stories, or anyone who wishes they can talk to animals will want to get their hands on this follow-up to George's The Rose Legacy (2018).(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2019, American Library Association.)