Murder in the Crooked House

Starred review from April 8, 2019
Set in 1983, Shimada’s brilliant sequel to 2015’s The Tokyo Zodiac Murders will thrill fans of golden age puzzle mysteries. Kozaburo Hamamoto, the president of the Hama Diesel company, has invited guests to celebrate Christmas at the unusual home he has constructed on Hokkaido. The building features intentionally sloping floors, and Hamamoto’s own rooms are in a tower resembling the Leaning Tower of Pisa, which can only be accessed by a drawbridge connecting it to the main structure. Self-styled sleuth Kiyoshi Mitarai investigates when a member of the party is stabbed to death with a knife inside a locked room. Oddly, the murder weapon has some string attached to it. Other bizarre elements include one of the victim’s hands being tied to the foot of a bed and a scream apparently issuing from the corpse a half hour after the killing. The tension rises as one impossibility follows another before an effective and dramatic reveal. Shimada combines fantastic crimes with a logical and fair solution likely to stump even the most astute readers.

April 15, 2019
A locked-room mystery in a uniquely built mansion is not so much a whodunit as a how-done-it...illustrated! A list of dramatis personae, a detailed drawing of the Ice Floe Mansion, and a plummy prologue theatrically set the scene. The story is divided into four "Acts," each of them in turn divided into "Scenes," with the final act preceded by a challenge to the reader. The puzzle begins when oil executive Kozaburo Hamamoto invites a diverse group of eight guests to his mansion on a snowy night. He embarrasses his daughter, Eiko, by suggesting that one of the male guests might be her new husband. Once everyone has been locked into their rooms, a series of unusual events begins. In her room at the top, guest Kumi Aikura sees a threatening man appear, impossibly, at her window. It's a snowy night, but no footprints show up anywhere around the house except when the party ventures out to see what they think is a corpse but turns out to be an antique doll Kozaburo purchased in Czechoslovakia. Whoever placed it there also decapitated it. The next morning, when guest Kazuya Ueda, the chauffeur of industrialist Eikichi Kikuoka, fails to appear for breakfast, his locked room is broken into and he's found dead, bound to his bed frame. Enter a team of police, led by DCI Saburo Ushikoshi, who begins the methodical questioning of suspects and the (armchair) sleuthing. The prolific Shimada (The Tokyo Zodiac Murders, 2015 deserves to have more of his work translated into English. He creates a delightfully intricate murder puzzle with retro charm, bound to tantalize readers.

COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.