Ladies and Gentlemen, The Bible!
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی
January 19, 2009
Several Bible stories get a rewrite in this funny collection by This American Life
contributing editor Goldstein (Lenny Bruce Is Dead
). In this version, David kills Goliath not so much for his people as for laughs, and Jonah's lesser-known brother Vito fears that God's hand in Jonah's stint inside the whale has less to do with Jonah than Vito's own role in a youthful penis-touching incident. In “My Troubles (A Work in Progress, by Joseph of N—),” a worried father-to-be deals with the ambiguities of having one's wife knocked up by an angel. The voices of these stories sound like that of the semiobservant Jew in the book's preface, who describes one of God's failed universes as consisting “of just one person—a man named Morris who sat in a room by himself, trying to decide whether to cuff his pants or let them drag.” With refashioned language and reimagined motivations, Goldstein's biblical characters evoke the kind of touching truths only found at the bottom of deep barrel laughs.
February 15, 2009
The author of Lenny Bruce Is Dead (2006) rewrites the Bible.
Goldstein is an alumnus of"This American Life," and he seems to be aiming for that show's mix of off-kilter humor and earnest tenderness. He achieves neither goal. In his hands, the sacred narratives of Christianity and Judaism are reduced to simpering, awkwardly contemporary little fables or bad jokes. Paradise is a garden full of trees"hung with fried eggs and home fries." Noah is an old crank who believes in the value of hard work; his son Ham is artsy, and Ham's wife spends her time on the ark painting flowers on rocks. The story of Jonah and the whale begins with a weirdly sexual childhood episode and develops into a narrative of Jonah's brother Vito's efforts to ensure that his slow, dreamy sibling gets laid. There are a few touching or amusing moments—Adam wondering"what it was like to be a kid"; Moses descending Mount Sinai,"his nerves shot"—but they're buried in precious, unilluminating metaphors and pointless, unfunny wackiness. It's the Bible as rewritten by a mildly precocious teenager.
Not as good as the original.
(COPYRIGHT (2009) KIRKUS REVIEWS/NIELSEN BUSINESS MEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.)
March 1, 2009
The deeply religious might be offended by This American Life contributor Goldsteins often-raucous reimaginings of Old Testament tales. But the less devout may find themselves chuckling at the unholy hilarity of it all. Here readers find Adam and Eve talking to God after being banished from the Garden of Eden: We get it, they screamed. Youve made your point. Now let us back in already. A misanthropic Noah hears a voice (inside his nose, no less) telling him to build an ark. An enterprising man operates a Golden Calf business to compete with the Almighty, marketing the bovine as a more laid-back, cud-chewing lord. Swarthy Samson, whos been shacking up with foxy Philistine Delilah, threatens a mortal enemy: I will make Jewish his penis with my teeth. After killing Goliath, an unsatisfied David finds that all he really wants to do is to make people laugh. Even God gets a dressing-down in a brave new biblical world thats part parable, part vaudeville: He was . . . tough, stubborn, and prone to yelling in your face for pretty much no reason.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2009, American Library Association.)
دیدگاه کاربران