Columbus Noir

December 15, 2019
The latest stage in Akashic's master plan to paint the world black is marked by 14 new stories whose most appealing features are their come-hither titles and the different shades of noir they invoke, from light gray to pitch black. The hallmark here is competent but unspectacular professionalism that ticks all the boxes but originality. Sex fuels the plots of Robin Yocum's "The Satin Fox," in which a vice cop's romance with a junkie stripper is threatened by blackmail; Kristen Lepionka's "Gun People," in which a wife takes up with one of the contractors upgrading the place her accountant husband has purchased; Craig McDonald's "Curb Appeal," which follows a woodworker's romance with an interior decorator to its all-too-logical end; Mercedes King's "An Agreeable Wife for a Suitable Husband," whose ill-assorted title couple plot to rid themselves of each other; Julia Keller's "All That Burns the Mind," in which an Ohio State University English teacher finds a sadly predictable way of dealing with two problem students; and Khalid Moalim's "Long Ears," whose heroine learns a great deal about an ancient accident and a present-day murder but keeps mum. None of the entries excels editor Welsh-Huggins' "Going Places," in which a rising politician's wife and fixer collude to shelter him from the consequences of his peccadilloes; the nearest competitors are Chris Bournea's "My Name Is Not Susan" (a retired football player's lover is suspected when he and his wife, the lover's friend, are murdered), Tom Barlow's "Honor Guard" (a chronically disappointing son negotiates frantically to keep his father out of prison after an argument with a stranger turns deadly), and Daniel Best's "Take the Wheel" (a tawdry, fast-moving tale of a pair of frenemies whose partnership in a coffee shop is threatened by some lethally laced heroin). The newly arrived Chinese student in Nancy Zefris' darkly comic "Foreign Study" manages to stumble through town without occasioning a single felony, and Laura Bickle's "The Dead and the Quiet," Lee Martin's "The Luckiest Man Alive," and Yolanda Tonette Sanders' "The Valley" are notable for their closing intimations of grace, that rarest of qualities in noir. As for Columbus, it comes across much like other Midwestern cities in noir stories, which may be the point.

COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

January 27, 2020
This superior Akashic noir anthology gathers 14 dark snapshots of Ohio’s capital, a very dangerous place indeed, with heavy drug use and murder touching down everywhere, from the German Village neighborhood to the statehouse. One highlight is Craig McDonald’s “Curb Appeal,” one of several invoking the homicidal search for housing. In the editor’s effective “Going Places,” a security man who covers up affairs for the governor gets pulled into a murder plot. In Mercedes King’s memorable “An Agreeable Wife for a Suitable Husband,” an abused wife who grew up “on a farm in Kentucky, slaughtering hogs” decides she’s had enough. Another strong entry is Laura Bickle’s “The Dead and the Quiet,” in which a young woman tries to score drugs, even “some Percs, not as good as Oxys, but she was desperate at this point.” The five tales in “Buckeye Betrayals,” the the third and final section, might lack the hard edge of the rest of the book, but, overall, noir fans should be well satisfied.

April 10, 2020

The first noir-themed collection put out by Akashic was Brooklyn Noir, edited by Pete Hamill. This volume, compiled by reporter Welsh-Huggins is the 101st edition; 13 more are already slated to appear. With one exception, the collections are city-based. Most of the tales are crime, not detective, stories--with a noir twist. Columbus used to be a sleepy place, but modern tensions have hit the metropolis with a bang. An opioid crisis, rising sales of heroin and Fentanyl, and tension between the well-off and the poor conspire to make the it a perilous place to navigate. The 14 stories here vary in quality but the best are little shockers, starting with Robin Yokum's revenge thriller, "The Satin Fox," and continuing with Nancy Zafris's "Foreign Study," an ugly tale of how an unsuspecting immigrant seeking to advance his education ends up lying on the ground, beaten and broken. VERDICT This attractive collection will appeal to lovers of crime noir and short crime fiction.--David Keymer, Cleveland

Copyright 2020 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.