Shapeshifters
A Journey Through the Changing Human Body
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی
April 2, 2018
An Edinburgh physician, Francis (Adventures in Human Being) undertakes a thoughtful exploration of diverse “transformations” of the human body. His topics include normal anatomical changes such as pregnancy and puberty; abnormal conditions such as anorexia and gigantism; the biological underpinnings of sleep, memory, and jet lag; and external efforts at reshaping the body such as through tattooing and cosmetic surgery. The chapters function less as formal essays than as observations of psychological and cultural links to biological phenomena. They tend to follow a similar formula: mythological, historical, or literary reference; scientific explanation; and anecdotal case—with some variation in the order. This formula, though effective, becomes overly predictable; the chapters are best read a few at a time, according to interest, the way one might browse encyclopedia entries. The scientific explanations often read like excerpts from a medical textbook (“The heart develops in the throat from the vessels of these gill arches, and the ductus arises from the residue of the sixth arch”) and may tax readers without a background in anatomy or biology. The standout chapters—which concern “Werewolves,” “Bodybuilding,” “Castration,” and “Prosthetics”—are those that do the best job of blending the book’s various interpretive lenses. Francis’s wide-ranging experience and curiosity produce fascinating samples of medical and cultural approaches to human change, albeit ones best consumed in small portions.
April 15, 2018
A physician/writer celebrates the dynamism and transformation of the human body and life.Francis (Adventures in Human Being: A Grand Tour from the Cranium to the Calcaneum, 2015, etc.), who regularly contributes to the London Review of Books and the Guardian, brings well-honed knowledge to these short chapters on the perpetual metamorphosis of the human body. What makes the book fun to read is not only the author's limpid anecdotes, but also his abiding marvel at the body's endless expressions. Francis ranges freely and skillfully from the strange to the elemental, such as pregnancy, "a primitive reminder that [the body's] changes are often beyond control; that bodies have their own rhythms, waypoints and fixed destinations." The author also explores the body's acts: sleep, for example, during which vital cerebral hygiene is at stake, and dreaming, which tends to our restless minds and "transforms our fear, shame and dark ambitions into...narratives." Francis is clearly drawn to curiosities, but he never makes them seem freakish--nor is he judgmental, but rather colorfully frank: Think steroids are the only road to a fine physique? Consider the risks of diabetes, infertility, depression, uncontainable bouts of rage, and wicked acne. These chapters can easily be read as stand-alones--the chapter on jetlag is followed by one on ancient and modern bone-setting techniques--but it's also satisfying to binge-read a number of them at once. While it might be disappointing to read that "we don't have much idea as to why we laugh"; appalling to consider that late-19th-century Vatican officials were still castrating young boys for its choir; and infuriating to read that the return of tuberculosis is a direct result of poverty, as are so many other maladies, Francis always makes you think.Captivating medical narratives that fit well alongside those of Oliver Sachs, Atul Gawande, Jerome Groopman, and Berton Roueché.
COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
دیدگاه کاربران