Only Child

September 16, 2002
"Sherlock Holmes is dead," intones Giovanni, a New York Mafia boss who hires street criminal Burke—who's made a career of killing child murderers and molesters—to solve the murder of his illegitimate teenage daughter, Vonni. Indeed, the whole Vachss oeuvre (this is the 14th novel to feature the avenging angel Burke) is a reminder that Conan Doyle's fictional sleuth would be clueless in the violent, sordid world of today's hard-boiled mystery. Burke doesn't search for clues so much as extort them by combining street smarts, his formidable intelligence and a deeply rooted outrage at the victimization of the young. Burke's fans will be delighted that he's returned to his home turf—the gritty back streets of New York City—where he's welcomed into the bosom of his ragtag band of delinquent colleagues. The novel has a compelling plot line (like a police procedural without the police), but the narrative is far from seamless. There are a couple of false starts as Burke searches for something to occupy his time, and the references to earlier novels will probably baffle newcomers. More seriously, the elaborate ruse Burke executes to identify and trap the killer is barely credible. But the noirish prose (a man's eyes are "the color of old dimes") is a pleasure, and Burke is an antihero of the old school. Though it doesn't break new artistic ground for Vachss, the book is another harrowing glimpse of the urban underworld from an author who clearly knows his terrain and whose sympathy for the truly innocent—the children—is unstinting.

September 1, 2002
Vachss, an attorney who specializes in juvenile justice and child-abuse cases and who has written widely on child abuse and endangerment, brings his expertise to his fiction. His Burke novels, noir to the point of total eclipse, travel the sordid world against which the real-life Vachss crusades. Vachss does nothing to soften the lines or fates of his characters. Burke himself is hard to warm to; he's a sometime assassin and perpetual con artist. As a narrator, Burke speaks and thinks harboiledese to the point of parody ("I've been to that school. Paid what the tuition cost"). Only the people he deals with, the ones who hire him to find or kill criminals even worse than him, make Burke seem somewhat palatable. This time a mafioso hires Burke to revenge the murder of his teenage daughter. Predictably, this throws Burke into a sewer--sex sold on the Internet and teens recruited for violent porn films. Repellant stuff, as always, but it will be sought out by devoted Vachss fans.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2002, American Library Association.)