Home Girl

Home Girl
افزودن به بوکمارک اشتراک گذاری 0 دیدگاه کاربران 4 (1)

مشارکت: عنوان و توضیح کوتاه هر کتاب را ترجمه کنید این ترجمه بعد از تایید با نام شما در سایت نمایش داده خواهد شد.
iran گزارش تخلف

فرمت کتاب

ebook

تاریخ انتشار

2019

Lexile Score

600

Reading Level

2-3

نویسنده

Alex Wheatle

ناشر

Akashic Books

شابک

9781617757716
  • اطلاعات
  • نقد و بررسی
  • دیدگاه کاربران
برای مطالعه توضیحات وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

نقد و بررسی

School Library Journal

July 1, 2019

Gr 7 Up-Fourteen-year-old Naomi Brisset, who is white, has been passed around the UK foster care system with no real sense of home. Since her mother died four years ago, Naomi took care of her alcoholic father, assuming many parenting roles. As such, she thinks of herself as an adult, refusing to ask for help when she needs it. That changes when she meets a black family, the Goldings, for a temporary placement by her overworked but patient social worker, Louise. Unlike past foster parents, the Goldings are genuine, lessening Naomi's instinct to run away, and she develops a soft spot for the Golding children, Sharyna and Pablo. The problem is that UK policy frowns upon placing white kids in black homes and that Naomi's friends from her previous group home, Kim and Nats, continue to be a poor influence on her decisions. Then a tragic accident forces Louise to find a new arrangement for Naomi's future. With a tough exterior and brash attitude, Naomi is an authentic character in an unfortunate yet accurate picture of modern-day foster care in the UK. The plot is a bit slow, and the dialogue, though fitting to Naomi's life situation, can be hard to understand at times. The ending is neither predictable nor sugarcoated, leaving readers rooting for this determined heroine. VERDICT An additional purchase for young adult realistic fiction collections.-Laura Jones, Argos Community Schools, IN

Copyright 2019 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.



Kirkus

July 1, 2019
Naomi Brisset, a 14-year-old white British girl in foster care, moves restlessly from home to home. After Naomi accuses her latest foster father of being "a perv with a big prick P," her social worker places her with a "second-generation British, West Indian" family, and Naomi begins to build familial connections with the parents, Tony and Colleen, who was also a foster child, and their two children, Pablo and Sharyna. Wheatle (Kerb-Stain Boys, 2018, etc.) has created a distasteful study in misogynoir, ableism, and homophobia. The book fast-tracks Naomi through situations where she leans into socially problematic scenarios with no apparent awareness: She begs her black foster mother to braid her hair so that she looks like Solange Knowles or Alicia Keys then is accused of cultural appropriation by a black girl who confronts her and is locked up in in-school suspension before being carted away. Wheatle's fictional Crongton leans into every negative stereotype of spaces where there are large concentrations of black communities. An opportunity to discuss issues of race in contemporary Britain is squandered when Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have a Dream" speech is quoted out of context, with Tony's father being labeled racist while Naomi's own racist commentary is not interrogated. The only queer relationship and characters in the story are demonized through violent and degrading behavior. The use of extreme trauma to further this story's development creates an unredeemable disconnect. (Fiction. 14-18)

COPYRIGHT(2019) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.




دیدگاه کاربران

دیدگاه خود را بنویسید
|