Plymouth Rocks!

August 14, 2020

K-Gr 2-In this informative picture book, the anthropomorphic Plymouth Rock describes its history. An unnamed fact checker, who appears to be a light-skinned young woman with red glasses and a bun, confirms or corrects the rock's story. The rock's rhyming prose is written on an unrolled scroll of paper. Red ink is used to clarify or dispel the rock's take on its own history. For example, "The disembarkers stepped on me, / first footfalls toward their liberty," claims the rock. However, the fact checker writes, "No large rock or stepping stone is mentioned in any of the travelers' journals or logs." Yolen also addresses the Indigenous community. The fact checker provides an honest account of how the colonizers impacted Native people: "More and more colonists soon arrived and took Native land to build their houses. They treated the Native people brutally and dishonestly." Both Yolen's text and Streed's cartoon illustrations are inviting. At times the poetry is a tad awkward ("Now placed in/ a portico, / my life once more/ is put on show") but in general, the poetry keeps pace with the prose. This title is best suited to an audience who has some familiarity with Plymouth Rock. VERDICT Humorous pictures supplement prose and poetry to create a unique, clever, engaging picture book about one aspect of early American history.-Anne Chapman Callaghan, Racine P.L., WI

Copyright 2020 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

September 15, 2020
Plymouth Rock is a great big liar. Fortunately, the googly-eyed, sentient hunk of granite has a fact checker, a bespectacled brown-skinned person with a very active red pen. Rock narrates in verse, informing readers of its glacial origins, the local wildlife, its Native neighbors, the arrival of English settlers, and the myths that gradually arose around it. As the rock versifies, the fact checker busily marks up Streed's cartoon spreads. "Hold on a minute!" reads one note on a fulsome description of how "the tribes" met the settlers "with a great burst of friendship, food, community." Another vigorously circled note reads, "Native people did greet the colonists and later shared food with them, but that is NOT the whole story." It's a clever device, allowing Rock to pontificate with corrective annotations to set the record straight, but unfortunately, Rock's story (as opposed to the story of the humans around it) is not interesting enough to sustain 32 pages. In fact, it's something of a snooze (it was moved, dropped, broken, chipped away at, be-plaqued, and literally enshrined). It's critical that readers learn that "settlers didn't just 'find' a new world, they colonized it" and that "the Native people...did not consider their world new," but this may not be the best vehicle. The narrative isn't substantial enough to sustain the needed counternarrative. (bibliography) (Informational picture book. 5-8)

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.