Jay Versus the Saxophone of Doom

October 15, 2016
Kootstra manages to breed a saxophone to a hockey stick and produce one sweet boy.It's the start of grade six. Enough said. But Jay Roberts kind of likes junior high. Home is Parry Sound, Ontario, a small, largely white burg on the shores of Georgian Bay, where Jay gets to exercise his obsession eight months of the year: hockey. And...the peerless Bobby Orr was born in Parry Sound. (Orr is important to the story, so it's too bad he is summed up as "easily skating around his opponents to find his way to the net for a goal or, if his team was unable to score, fading back to play his position as a defensemen." Good thing that Orr's reputation precedes him.) Two nemeses will test Jay's patience and confidence this year: bully Mick and the saxophone, an instrument Jay gets saddled with and for which he has little affection. But this story has the buoyancy of a life preserver, and humor's sprinkled around like salt on an icy sidewalk. "All your father and I expect of you is to do your best, your very best, at whatever you do, and try not to throw up." With a cool hand, Kootstra also gives hidden depths to band geek Ben, draws the commonalities between a stick and a sax, tells two convincing stories about confidence and the journey being the point, and fashions a sharp visualization to end the tale. Orr's afterword has the final words--on passion, struggle, respect--qualities Kootstra has spun into her story with understated dexterity. (Fiction. 8-12)

COPYRIGHT(2016) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

November 15, 2016
Grades 3-6 Sixth-grader Jay lives and breathes hockey, so he's not pleased when he gets to music class and learns he (and other students) must play a solo before the entire class shortly after Christmas break, something bound to cut into his time on the ice. To make matters worse, he gets stuck with the saxophoneone of the more difficult instruments to learn. Hockey takes precedent for Jay, until he realizes he will never complete the solo if he doesn't spend some serious time with the saxophone. Oh, the woes of navigating sixth grade! Family dynamics and friendships aboundconflicts, bullies, and humor, too. Kootstra's love of hockey and her knowledge of middle-schoolers are evident here. She inserts pithy Game Tips (which are advice tips on life, not hockey) from time to time, as well as letters (in a handwritten font), lists, and cartoonish spot illustrations. The afterword letter of encouragement from the great hockey star Bobby Orr leaves readers with a serious takeaway.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2016, American Library Association.)