America through Foreign Eyes

May 1, 2020
Astute observations about both the expanse of American "civilization" and the dilution of its "exceptionalism." The United States has always been subject to scrutiny and criticism, from de Tocqueville to Borat, and Casta�eda--the global professor of political science and Latin American studies at NYU who served as the foreign minister of Mexico from 2000 to 2003--is a rather avuncular critic of many aspects of American society. Via his meandering notes on the middle class, humor, "dysfunctional" democracy, racial issues, and other topics, he provides mostly valuable and useful analysis. Interestingly, he counters some of the usual, often heard criticism from Europeans and Latin Americans about the American "sameness," uniformity, and homogeneity, examining in comparative graphs the rise of the middle class. While it was, on one hand, the envy of the world--cars, TVs, and other gadgets in every household--it masked the "underlying diversity" that made up the country and largely excluded significant populations of blacks, Natives, and Latinos. The relative equality of income distribution peaked in the late 1960s and has grown increasingly unequal since. Casta�eda also examines the country's much-vaunted (and highly problematic) systems of meritocracy and expectation of social mobility--and how the latter trend has declined below the levels of many European countries. The other "defining trait" of America--after uniformity and obsession with money--is "exceptionalism," a myth that the author explodes, quoting Mexican novelist Carlos Fuentes: "The United States has been the bearer of a nationalism as aggressive and self-celebratory as any European imperial power." In the last, hard-hitting chapter, "The Unforgivable," Casta�eda explores how America's grand Enlightenment ideals have been trampled by a "breach of contract with liberalism and tolerance" in terms of "mass incarceration, the death penalty, guns, and intelligent design." A largely detached observer offers a series of digestible, timely assessments of the U.S.

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.