Time and Chance

January 21, 2002
When Christ and His Saints Slept
was Penman's popular account of the 12th-century struggle for England's throne. This book, the second of a planned trilogy, begins after Henry II has inherited the crown and married Eleanor of Aquitaine—a mature beauty and a wealthy ruler in her own right. Henry II is a confident leader, but he is also wise enough to appreciate his politically astute wife. His only other trusted adviser is Thomas Becket. Diplomatic and suave, Becket is the perfect complement for a rough-hewn young king. When he makes his chancellor archbishop of Canterbury, Henry believes he is creating an indomitable union of church and state. Becket, however, becomes an adamant protector of ecclesiastical power. The resulting conflict will climax in Becket's murder. In her five previous historical novels, Penman has exhibited a cool, almost academic style balanced by a penetrating sympathy, her fiction adhering faithfully to fact while making the past fully present. She would seem the ideal author to turn these outsized players in a royal drama into real people. Unfortunately, this long-anticipated novel lacks animation. The main characters never come to life, and Becket, in particular, remains a cipher: Penman never ventures inside this saint in the making, nor does she successfully explicate his conversion. She is more confident with her wholly imagined characters, but their vividness only serves to underscore the lifeless quality of the principals, and even the well-defined characters too often indulge in tedious and unbelievable expository monologues. 10-city author tour.(Mar. 4)Forecast:Penman may not attract new fans with this disappointing offering, but the many readers who have been waiting seven years for it to appear will snap it up regardless.

November 1, 2001
Penman continues her parade of British historicals with the story of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine.

Copyright 2001 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

February 15, 2002
This vividly rendered historical novel expertly captures the pomp, pageantry, and complexity of the reign of King Henry II of England. The second installment of a medieval trilogy that opened with Penman's widely acclaimed "When Christ and His Saints Slept" (1994)," "this sweeping saga re-creates the drama, the intrigue, and the passion that distinguished the lives of Henry Plantagenet, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and Thomas Becket. Though the subject has been exhaustively chronicled in both history and literature, this fictionalized account of the trials and tribulations of this prominent trio of historical figures manages to breathe new life into a familiar story. As this assortment of multifaceted personalities makes the decisions that will determine their destinies, Penman displays a remarkable ability to communicate both the thoughts and the feelings of her real-life characters sympathetically. Authentically detailed and artfully crafted, this larger-than-life epic will draw readers inexorably into an emotional vortex culminating in both tragedy and triumph. (Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2002, American Library Association.)