Return to Oak Valley

October 28, 2002
Historical romance writer Busbee (Swear by the Moon, etc.) sets her debut contemporary in a remote California valley full of gorgeous scenery, thriving ranches and hard feelings, particularly between the Ballingers and Grangers. Shelly Granger's youthful romance with Sloan Ballinger seemed to bring the warring clans together; then she discovered him cheating and fled Oak Valley for New Orleans. Many years later, the suicide of her beloved brother, Josh, forces Shelly back home, where she discovers several things Josh had concealed from her—including his gambling addiction, his dismantling of the family's cattle business, his dubious friends and the fact that he may have set up the betrayal that drove her away years earlier. Little by little, Shelly works to restore the family fortune and rebuild her trust with Sloan. Dense backstory and an overpopulation of minor characters make the book slow going at times, and Busbee's assumption that a smart modern woman would isolate herself for decades from the home, man and family she adores on the flimsiest of evidence is romance writing at its silliest. Despite its modern date and explicit sex scenes, there's little here that feels truly contemporary. Still, Busbee's descriptive tale is sure to please those who like their love stories lush and laid-back.

December 1, 2002
Shelley Granger returns to her isolated California town after 17 years of self-imposed exile because her older brother, Josh, whom she revered, committed suicide. As the last remaining Granger, she intends to stay and take care of the family business but finds out that Josh has sold most of the cattle, and left her in debt. She has trouble believing that he really killed himself, but the more she learns the more she realizes that she's put Josh on a pedestal. She also has to face Sloan Ballinger, the man who drove her away all those years ago. Shelley fell in love with him even though he's a Ballinger and her family has hated his since just after the Civil War, and sure enough he betrayed her. Now Sloan wants to try again, but she doesn't know if she can trust him. Busbee's enjoyable western soap opera is filled with sexy characters just begging for a sequel.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2002, American Library Association.)