The Flight of Gemma Hardy

Both fans of JANE EYRE and those who have never read Brontæ's original will find much to like about this retelling of the classic tale of an orphaned girl's quest to find love, respect, and a home. Author Margot Livesey has set her version in the 1950s and '60s, molding twentieth-century details and situations to Brontæ's general plot. It's difficult to imagine a better narrator than Davina Porter for Gemma's story, which is set primarily in mainland Scotland and the Orkneys. Porter's engaging Scots accent gives listeners a strong sense of place, and she easily voices British English and Icelandic as needed. Listeners will appreciate Porter's consistent characterizations, which are judiciously punched up with emotion to fit this modernization of a classic story. C.B.L. (c) AudioFile 2012, Portland, Maine

Starred review from October 10, 2011
Inspired by Jane Eyre, Livesey (The House on Fortune Street) offers vibrant prose and a feisty heroine in her fascinating sixth novel, set in Scotland in the early 1960s. After 10-year-old Gemma Hardy’s parents die, she is taken in by a kind uncle, much to his wife’s dismay. When her uncle dies, the novel takes on shades of Cinderella as Gemma (who had been accepted by her cousins) is made into a scullery maid. Though her aunt attempts to break her down, Gemma works hard in school, earning a scholarship place at the Claypool boarding school. Again little more than a slave, Gemma learns how to survive among the working girls. When the school closes, Gemma takes a position in the Orkneys, where she will live at the estate of the mysterious Sinclair and look after his wild niece, Nell. She and Sinclair fall in love, but Sinclair has a secret that drives Gemma to change, as well as inspiring her to trace her Icelandic roots. Although guardian angels and kind strangers turn up like an army of deus ex machinas, these plot missteps don’t detract from Gemma’s self-possessed determination. Captivating and moving, this book is a wonderful addition to Livesey’s body of work.