Harold's Treasure Hunt

April 15, 2020
Harold takes his purple crayon on a newly minted adventure, meeting pirates and lots of sea life. Designed to mimic the look and feel of Johnson's original series, this anonymously composed and illustrated spinoff (title-page credit notwithstanding) follows the pajama-clad lad on a nighttime outing onto a pirate ship, off a plank at sword point, into and out of the ocean, and finally through a cave where, once he draws a window "that the sun shined through big and bright," he finds "the best treasure ever" in his own bedroom toy box. Along the way he encounters a mermaid (discreetly clad in a camisole) but passes by because he doesn't want to "interupt" [sic] her and an octopus who is no help with directions because "they didn't see eye to eye," whatever that means. In the purple-dominated illustrations the pirate and the mermaid are just outlines, and so take on the color of the background, but Harold's exposed hands and round head have been darkened just enough to create a whiff of racial ambiguity. This has absolutely none of the magic of the 1955 classic, and it's hard not to wonder what Johnson might make of it; the Ruth Krauss Foundation holds the copyright, but the identities of the actual author and illustrator are carefully concealed. Could have been a slick pastiche...given a spell check run and better art and writing. (Picture book. 3-5)

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.