
Not Our Kind
A Novel
کتاب های مرتبط
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی

September 3, 2018
The pseudonymous Zeldis masterfully transports readers to 1947 New York to depict the relationships that develop between a young Jewish woman and a Protestant family. Eleanor Moskowitz and Patricia Bellamy run into each other—or rather, their cabs collide—on Park Avenue, and the elegant Patricia invites the job-seeking Eleanor to her high-end apartment to help the young woman recover from the jolt. Patricia’s 13-year-old daughter, Margaux, an angry polio survivor who walks with the aid of a stick, is immediately drawn to Eleanor’s intelligent, forthright demeanor, and Eleanor finds young Margaux equally appealing. Patricia is also intrigued by Eleanor, even though she has “never entertained a Jew in her apartment before.” Eleanor, a Vassar grad, is hired to tutor Margaux in the Bellamy home, but Patricia’s bigoted husband, Wynn, is resistant to the idea. Eleanor accompanies the family on a summer retreat in Connecticut to continue working with Margaux, and passions begin to rise between Eleanor and Tom, Patricia’s brother, who joins the family in their summer home after a stint in France. Lively descriptions of 1940s clothing and culture complement the realistic characters. This is a vivid, winning novel.

A freak cab accident on Park Avenue complicates the lives of Eleanor Moskowitz, an intelligent, articulate Jewish girl, and Patricia Bellamy, a wealthy, class-conscious WASP. Narrator Tavia Gilbert does some remarkable vocal calisthenics, creating a full cast of multidimensional characters in 1947 New York City. Gilbert captures the sound and feel of the postwar period, with its anti-Semitism, classism, and sexism. When Eleanor accepts a position as tutor to Margeaux, the Bellamy daughter, a polio survivor, Gilbert delivers a teenager who is whiny one moment and solid the next. Her male characters are well drawn, offering identifiably different voices for Patricia's brother, Tom, and husband, Win. Eleanor's immigrant mother, a milliner, is treated with respect, her accent bearing no trace of caricature. Gilbert weaves the novel's complicated relationships into a compelling tapestry. S.J.H. � AudioFile 2018, Portland, Maine
دیدگاه کاربران