The Oyster Thief

August 27, 2018
Faruqi, author of the factory farming exposé Project Animal Farm, takes to a fairy tale format to urge human empathy with ocean life, creating an ecologically informed but whimsically imagined underwater culture as the setting for her magical, if rather cynical, mermaid-human love story. Apprentice mermaid apothecary Coralline is uninspired by her immanent, upwardly mobile wedding. After an oil spill makes her little brother ill, she embarks on a quest for an elixir that could heal him. Coralline and her anxious animal friends rescue human Izar, who has been tossed into the ocean by his enemies and transformed into a merman. Izar shares an important clue to aid their search, but keeps secret his identity as heir to the mining corporation Ocean Dominion and inventor of an underwater fire device that’s poised to destroy all mermaid life. Coralline and Izar’s bonding leads them to question their respective commitments. Adult fans of movies such as The Little Mermaid and Finding Nemo will find Coralline’s adventures delightful, and Faruqi’s caricatured villains are satisfyingly hateful, but romance fans will be disappointed that Izar and Coralline’s personal connection lacks fire. This parable is more endearing than enduring.

September 15, 2018

Young mermaid Coralline is about to marry and become an apothecary's apprentice, but after a damaging oil spill leaves her brother near death, she must give up everything to proceed on a quest for a magic elixir to heal him. Human Izar, who works for the company that caused the spill, has plans to uncover riches through ocean mining, which would cause the merpeople's extinction. After he's kidnapped and thrown overboard, Izar is changed into a merman. He eventually joins Coralline on her mission in hopes that the elixir will change him back to human, only to fall in love with her. Faruqi (Project Animal Farm) creates a full-fledged, highly believable merworld using beautiful imagery and realistic character development and demonstrating a deep understanding of ocean conservation and marine life. VERDICT Highly recommended for readers who enjoy love stories set in fantastical worlds, with YA crossover appeal.--Lucy Roehrig, Ann Arbor Dist. Lib., MI

Copyright 2018 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.