The Orphan of Salt Winds
کتاب های مرتبط
- اطلاعات
- نقد و بررسی
- دیدگاه کاربران
نقد و بررسی
October 22, 2018
In her hauntingly gothic debut, Brooks beautifully mixes bittersweet youthfulness with the stinging pain of past memories. Told from the perspective of the 10-year-old orphan Virginia on the eve of WWII in the English countryside, the story begins when Virginia is adopted by a young couple and brought to Salt Winds, a large estate at the edge of a marsh. Virginia finds herself in the middle of tensions with her adoptive parents’ marriage, worried that they’ll want to send her back to the orphanage. Also, unbeknownst to her new father, Clem, a man has been dropping by to see his wife. Virginia feels most at home with Clem, who teaches her about marshland birds. The marsh also serves as a metaphor for Virginia’s precarious situation—the tides turn quickly, shifting the landscape and opening quicksand pits. When a man parachutes from the sky into the marsh, Clem tries to rescue him even though he could be a German soldier. In alternating chapters, the far-reaching aftershocks of Clem’s decision are slowly unveiled as Virginia, now an old woman wandering the halls of Salt Winds, contemplates her past. This quietly unsettling tale holds its secrets close, making for a powerful story of loss and longing.
November 15, 2018
A remote house, a treacherous marsh, and an orphan child are the ingredients in this atmospheric gothic tale from a new British writer.Virginia Wrathmell is 86 and frail when readers first meet her in Brooks' evocative debut, reminiscent of Daphne du Maurier's haunted dramas set in wild places. It's December 2015, Virginia lives alone in spooky, decaying Salt Winds, on the edge of Tollbury Marsh, and on the last day of the year she plans to walk out to the marsh and allow it to swallow her. But in another timeline, dated December 1939, orphaned Virginia, age 10, is being introduced to Salt Winds by her kindly new adoptive father, Clem. Brooks' tale shuttles between these two eras, revealing how sensitive Virginia's childhood was swallowed up by events inside the house and on the marsh beyond. Clem's wife, Lorna, not only expresses little of her husband's welcoming excitement toward Virginia, but also seems unable to shake off the attentions of creepy local widower Max Deering, to whom Lorna was once engaged. Deering, who takes a lingering interest in Virginia, too, is forever underfoot, never more so than when Clem disappears on the marsh, searching for a German airman whose plane has crashed there. With Clem absent, a mysterious man in the attic, and villainous, mustachioed Max turning up at all hours, the atmosphere at Salt Winds becomes both secretive and feverish. And in the 2015 storyline, the house is visited by an impulsive young woman whose ties to the past compel Virginia to change--and darken--her plans for this, her last day. Ambiguous and infused with both fairy tale and matters more threatening, Brooks' novel is persuasively descriptive--"where sky, sand, and water dissolved into nothing and nowhere"--but doesn't quite knit together. Deering's semifarcical lechery, Lorna's perplexing psychology, and the ends left dangling rob the story of conviction.A committed, stylish mystery better at composing its mood music than pulling all the notes together.
COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
November 15, 2018
According to 86-year-old Virginia's plan, New Year's Eve 2015 is not only her last day in Salt Winds, the bleak old house on Tollbury Marsh, but also her last day on Earth. She has lived at Salt Winds since she was a 10-year-old orphan, brought there by her adoptive parents, Lorna and Clem. Though Lorna is distant, Clem is attentive and kind. But an air of menace hangs over the house. Friend-of-the-family Max Deering, sleek and overly familiar, is always hanging about. And Clem's repeated warnings about the marsh's dangers are reinforced when a German fighter plane crashes, setting in motion a series of calamities. In her debut, Brooks convincingly renders a child trying to make sense of the confusing and mysterious world of adults; Virginia is observant, but she doesn't always get things right, and her efforts to control events can have unintended consequences. Back in 2015, her "farewell tour" of the house is interrupted by the appearance of Sophie, a runaway teenager who evokes protectiveness but also stirs up old hatreds. A careful buildup of suspense will keep readers guessing and glued to the pages.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2018, American Library Association.)
دیدگاه کاربران