World Without Darkness

April 15, 2018
With only a few days to get back to Sunrise Valley before the next black fog, Pig and his friends undertake a desperate trek across the wastelands.Short on storyline but long on encounters with strange residents met along the way, this sequel to The Dam Keeper takes Pig, Fox, Hippo, and Van (the last apparently a lizard but strongly resembling a Kermit the Frog puppet) from the teeming, smoggy streets of Frogtown through cities of beavers and moles, a meeting with a group of nomads led by a wolf, and finally a brush with a scary smoke monster. The art, done without inked lines in luminous, gracefully brushed colors, has a distinctive and superficially pretty look. However, forms and backdrops tend to be rendered as vague, indistinct blobs, often in dim lighting, and on some pages they are so squeezed into tiny panels that at times their nature, or any action that might be taking place, is hard to discern. This stylization is particularly noticeable in the animal cast, much of which is so cute and snub-nosed as to be unidentifiable without prompts in the dialogue. The influence of the Academy Award-nominated short film that inspired this spinoff remains in the cinematic storyboarding and visual humor--but readers who aren't already cued into the plot, characters, and overall scenario will flounder.Moves the story about an inch--handsome but inessential. (Graphic fantasy. 7-11)

COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

July 1, 2018

Gr 3-6-This graphic novel is based on a short film of the same name, focused on a pig trying to keep a dark fog from engulfing his small town; this second installment finds Pig on a quest with his friends, seeking answers about the deadly fog and encountering new challenges. The most appealing element of this tale is its hazy sweetness as this loyal band of companions amble along toward an uncertain fate. The digital, watercolor-style art is organic and comfortable, a bit like a superb storyboard. Our view of Pig's plight remains incomplete, as this is the second of three volumes. Getting just a slice of the action may leave readers curious to go back and forward for the rest of the picture-though, since it's told in such a mellow tone (except for a couple of terrifying moments), kids might be satisfied with this one glimpse into Pig's world. VERDICT For fantasy-loving older elementary and middle grade readers.-Emilia Packard, Austin, TX

Copyright 2018 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.