The Girl in the Well Is Me

December 14, 2015
Rivers (Finding Ruby Starling) adheres to the advice that fiction writers “give their characters trouble” in this psychological horror story. Over a day and night trapped in a well, Kammie Summers, 11, recounts a horrific year. After her father’s incarceration for a heinous crime, a beloved relative dies of cancer, and a bus kills the family dog outside their New Jersey home (which the bank is repossessing). The Summers relocate to “Nowheresville,” Texas, exchanging a life of plasma-screen TVs and horseback-riding lessons for a trailer where Kammie shares a bedroom with a brother who doesn’t like her anymore. Asthmatic Kammie doles out the details of her downward mobility while the mean girls who tricked her into falling into the well look down and laugh. Rivers writes intense scenes of hallucinatory prose as the sky darkens, and oxygen deprivation causes Kammie to imagine dead goats beneath her feet, spiders attacking her legs, and the company of a French-speaking coyote. The stream-of-consciousness narration recalls Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper,” but claustrophobics will probably want to read something else. Ages 10–13. Agent: Jennifer Laughran, Andrea Brown Literary Agency.

Eleven-year-old Kammie falls down a narrow well shaft and has to rely on the class mean girls to go for help. Narrator Michele O. Medlin expertly renders the girl's thoughts as they transition from mad to scared to resigned while she mulls over her possible death and the events that have taken her family from an upper-middle-class New Jersey community to a trailer park in "Nowheresville," Texas. Medlin's voice sounds believably young, and she realistically captures Kammie's wide range of emotions, avoiding melodrama and firmly locking listeners' attention on her predicament. This potentially dark tale is lightened by Kammie's sense of humor and imagination. At one point, for example, she imagines she's visited by a French-speaking coyote. Perfect for family listening. C.B.L. Winner of AudioFile Earphones Award © AudioFile 2016, Portland, Maine