The Monstrous

Starred review from September 7, 2015
Datlow, horror anthologist extraordinaire, brings together all things monstrous in this excellent reprint anthology of 20 horror stories that explore the ever-widening definition of what makes a monster, with nary a misstep. The varied sources of monstrosity include a very troubled kindergarten teacher, a catering company that puts humans on the menu, and spirit-devouring creatures out of Japanese mythology, all creating distinctive microcosms where monsters reign in many forms. In Gemma Files’s “A Wish from a Bone,” an archeological reality show filming in Sudan uncovers evidence of the Terrible Seven, ancient beings who are bent on destruction and domination. Adam-Troy Castro’s “The Totals” skewers bureaucracy and the daily grind by populating a drinking hole with monsters, who create mayhem, commit murder, and kvetch with their deadly coworkers with the same sense of ennui felt by any office drone. Other standouts by Sofia Samatar, Dale Bailey, and Christopher Fowler round out this atmospheric and frequently terrifying collection.

October 15, 2015

The only direction editor Datlow gave her contributors when compiling this collection was that she didn't want any human monsters. While some of the ten stories here skirt that rule, there are a nice variety of inhuman beasties as well. A moody Japanese tale from Jeffrey Ford, "A Natural History of Autumn," opens the collection, followed by Peter Straub's school-set riff on Cinderella, "Ashputtle." Other standouts include Adam-Troy Castro's "The Totals," which gives us a competitive monster office and "Down Among the Dead Men" from Jack Dann and Gardner Dozois about a vampire imprisoned in a World War II concentration camp. The anthology also finishes strong with Josh Logan's Scottish-set "Corpsemouth," the single story original to this collection. VERDICT The list of contributors, including Gemma Files, Caitlin R. Kiernan, Adam L.G. Nevill, and Kim Newman, will be enough to get horror fans excited. The assortment of styles means that there is a monster here for everyone's taste.--MM

Copyright 2015 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.