The Scribe

Starred review from July 27, 2015
Set in Atlanta in 1881, this superior whodunit from Edgar-finalist Guinn (The Resurrectionist) stars Thomas Canby, a former detective on the Atlanta Police Force, who lost his job after a false accusation of taking bribes. When someone murders barber Alonzo Lewis, “the richest Negro in Atlanta,” severing his head and carving the letter M on his forehead, Canby’s old boss recalls the disgraced detective. The powers that be have suppressed the news, as the city is relying on the success of the International Cotton Exposition to revitalize municipal finances. Another wealthy African-American is killed soon afterward, but this time the letter A is left as the killer’s mark. Canby, who is white, partners with the city’s first African-American police officer, Cyrus Underwood. Since Underwood was the first to find both dead men, he himself is an obvious suspect, but the plot takes numerous turns before the final, painful resolution. The richness of the characters and period detail make the prospect of a sequel welcome. Agent: Emma Sweeney, Emma Sweeney Agency.

Lloyd James gives an understated performance in this sequel to THE RESURRECTIONIST. Disgraced detective Thomas Canby is called back to postwar Atlanta to investigate a series of ghoulish murders. Canby is partnered with Cyrus Underwood, Atlanta's first black detective. It seems the killer is targeting wealthy black men, eviscerating the victims, then carving an alphabet letter into their flesh. James is completely convincing, giving the principals depth and dimension. Each character is instantly identifiable--man or woman, white or black, Northerner or Southerner. Guinn offers a tale of Gothic horror with enough credibility to make the fiction seem real, thanks to a truly malevolent villain and a flawless delivery by James. S.J.H. © AudioFile 2015, Portland, Maine