My Best Friend Is a Goldfish

February 15, 2018
What makes for a great best friend?The protagonist of this book says: "Best friends enjoy the same things. // They play together all the time. / And they always get along with each other." But suddenly, the narrator, dressed as an astronaut, and the child dressed as a pirate the protagonist has been playing with have a falling out. Now the narrator must turn to animals to find the solace of similarity. Cycling through the family's dog, cat, hamster, and goldfish as possible new best friends, the narrator analyzes their relationships, but in the end, they are all found wanting. Sniffing things and eating on the floor alongside Murphy might be fun, but the dog has his own canine friends. The goldfish seems to be a good companion, but in reality, Fishy Robert just swim and eats. Finally the narrator realizes that friends don't always like doing the same things: even as "cookies and milk are different...they're still perfect for each other." When the protagonist's original playmate walks down the street, they fall right into their old relationship and go play tag. The cartoonish digital illustrations dominated by bold, primary colors depict both children with pale skin. They extend the text amusingly, but this is a one-note book about friendship.Better books about friendship exist, making this strictly an additional purchase. (Picture book. 4-6)

COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

February 15, 2018
Grades 1-3 A playground spat with his best friend leads a child to go down a list of possible replacements for her. Each turns out to be deficient in some way: Murphy the dog likes to eat on the floor and run in the park with other pets; Gus the cat hunts live mice; Hercules the hamster stuffs his cheek pouches with food; Fishy Robert the goldfish eats and swims around . . . and nothing else. Following his reluctant insight that friends can be like cookies and milkdifferent yet still perfect for each other his friend trots up and taps him on the shoulder. You know what you are? What? You're it! This final dialogue exchange might be a bit perplexingit's not immediately clear which character is speaking which phrasebut through facial expressions and other visual cues, Jevons artfully makes the narrator's reasons for rejecting each alternative candidate, most of which are not explicitly stated, perfectly clear. A low-key and less violent (if also less comical) alternative to Emily Jenkins' Tiger and Badger (2016).(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2018, American Library Association.)