Tuesday Nights in 1980

January 25, 2016
First-time novelist Prentiss vividly conjures a colorful love triangle set in the gritty, art-soaked world of downtown New York in 1980. Raul Engales is a painter throwing himself into the scene as a means to escape his past in Argentina, where war has cast everything into shadow. James Bennett is an up-and-coming art critic with an overwhelming gift: synesthesia: “an image was manufactured into a bodily sensation... applesauce tasted like sadness and winter was the color blue.” The fulcrum is Lucy Olliason, a naive beauty from Idaho, drawn to New York by a postcard of the skyline she found on the side of the road. Prentiss shines when showing us James’s powers of perception. Impressive, too, is her ability to create an atmosphere that crackles with possibility as well as foreboding. She sprinkles verisimilitude throughout the SoHo scene—Laurie Anderson sings at a party at Raul’s squat; Lucy spies Keith Haring tagging a subway station; news of “Jean-Michel” and his neologistic SAMO tags are everywhere and nowhere, a spectral presence imprinting on Raul’s psyche. Structured over a year beset by tragedy, the story belongs to the two great men, artist and critic; Lucy’s beauty is her most distinguishing characteristic. One yearns for more time spent on the women artists who are minor characters, James’s magnanimous wife, Marge, and Lucy’s sometime roommate. Nevertheless, this is a bold and auspicious debut. Agent: Claudia Ballard, WME Entertainment.

Starred review from February 1, 2016
Prentiss' sweeping debut follows three intertwining lives through the swirling energy, burning excitement, and crushing disappointment of New York City's rapidly shifting art world at the dawn of the 1980s. It's Dec. 31, 1979, and James Bennett, a synesthetic rising star of art criticism, and his also-brilliant pregnant wife are toasting the new decade at the kind of swanky art-scene party they prefer to avoid. Also at the party: painter Raul Engales, a charismatic Argentinian expatriate who's done his best to erase his past life and is now poised, though he doesn't know it yet, to become the darling of the art world. And: in a bar downtown later that night, Raul catches the (gorgeous) eye of 21-year-old Lucy Marie Olliason, recently transplanted from Ketchum, Idaho, in love with the city, and ready to fall in love with the artists in it. Their stories crash into each other like dominoes--the critic, the artist, and the muse--their separate futures and personal tragedies inextricably linked. The particulars of their connections, romantic and artistic, are too big and too poetic to be entirely plausible, but then, this is not a slice-of-life novel: this is a portrait of an era, an intoxicating Manhattan fairy tale. Prentiss' characters--rich, nuanced, satisfyingly complicated--are informed not only by their emotional lives, but also by their intellectual and artistic ones; their relationships to art are as lively and essential as their relationships to each other. But while the novel is elegantly infused with an ambient sense of impending loss--this is New York on the cusp of drastic gentrification--it miraculously manages to dodge the trap of easy nostalgia, thanks in large part to Prentiss' wry humor. As affecting as it is absorbing. A thrilling debut.

COPYRIGHT(2016) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Starred review from February 1, 2016
Prentiss' debut novel captures the eruption of creativity and commodification precipitated by New York City's 1970s crash into fiscal and criminal chaos. Painter Raul appears within this maelstrom after fleeing Buenos Aires before the onset of the Dirty War. He vamps his way into free studio space and, with the gruff mentorship of a veteran artist named Arlene, rapidly ascends toward the blazing beacon of fame. Art critic James makes a splash as he draws on the strange revelations of his synesthesia, which jumbles his senses and intensifies the force fields of the art he scrutinizes. Lucy is a lovely innocent from Idaho who stumbles her way into the molten heart of the art scene, at once foolish and brave. An agile, imaginative, knowledgeable, and seductive writer, Prentiss combines exquisite sensitivity with unabashed melodrama to create an operatic tale of ambition and delusion, success and loss, mystery and crassness. Though some characters are predictable, most, especially James and his wife, are fresh, funny, ardent, and magnetizing. Prentiss' insights into this brash art world are sharply particularized and shrewd, but she also tenderly illuminates universal sorrows, beautiful horrors, and lush moments of bliss. In all, a vital, sensuous, edgy, and suspenseful tale of longing, rage, fear, compulsion, and love.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2016, American Library Association.)