The Right Attitude to Rain

August 28, 2006
The third novel featuring well-to-do and somewhat-nosy philosopher Isabel Dalhousie continues McCall Smith's exploration of the rights and wrongs of everyday life, with Isabel's thoughtful presence providing decidedly more intellectual punch than the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency. When Jamie, a young musician, begins to show interest in Isabel, her stirred feelings threaten to overwhelm her even keel, throwing her into ethical crisis. To what degree are our lives dictated by biological imperatives and desires? Does the meaning of art arise from the art itself or its audience? Are white lies permissible, and if so, when? What does the well-off individual owe the homeless man on the corner? Out-of-town visitors to Edinburgh—Americans, no less—provide further touchstones for all manner of ethical mulling as well as the grist of the book's mystery: does Angie, a young, inscrutable woman betrothed to a wealthy Dallas bachelor, Tom Bruce, have her eyes set on true love or money? At times Isabel's intense dedication to mindfulness borders on the didactic, but love comes to the rescue, nicely illustrating the book's most important philosophical puzzle: how is it that people find real happiness, and what does it have to do with loving rather than thinking?

Davina Porter, Alexander McCall Smith, and Isabel Dalhousie are a perfect trio in this third Dalhousie story. Isabel has guests who introduce her to a newly engaged Dallas couple. Narrator Davina Porter skillfully conveys many characters and even more personality types. Her Dallas and Scots accents are exceptional, along with her tone for conversational debates, befitting Isabel's career as a philosopher. With so much romance in the air, both Isabel and her niece, Cat, fall in love, spicing up the plot. A surprise conclusion renders listeners clamoring for more. The novel is light enough on mystery to also be enjoyed by those who enjoy straight fiction. S.G.B. (c) AudioFile 2007, Portland, Maine