Guilty Not Guilty

September 30, 2019
Bestseller Francis’s plodding fifth solo addition to his father’s horse-racing series (after 2018’s Crisis) has only a tangential connection to the turf. The Hon. William Gordon-Russell, a self-employed actuary who prefers to be called plain old Bill Russell, is preparing for his duties as a racetrack steward when he receives some devastating news: his beloved wife, Amelia, has been discovered strangled in their Oxfordshire home. Bill’s brother-in-law, Joe Bradbury, accuses Bill of the crime, and the police make him their prime suspect on the theory that he killed Amelia to collect on her life insurance. Bill, in turn, believes that Joe, who found the body and who’d sent Amelia threatening and harassing emails, is the murderer. After Bill is brought in for questioning, he becomes a pariah and sets out to prove his innocence and Joe’s guilt. Suspension of disbelief is lessened by such details as Bill believing, inaccurately, that leading questions are impermissible on cross-examination. The twist ending will surprise few mystery fans. That Francis has done much better work in the past suggests that a return to form is possible. Agent: Ed Wilson, Johnson & Alcock (U.K.).

Listeners who expect murders in horse barns or on racetracks will be disappointed with this new audio mystery by Felix Francis, son of the late Dick Francis, who was known for writing about the track. This psychological mystery, narrated by Martin Jarvis, spends more time in the courtroom than in the world of horses. Jarvis portrays Bill Russell as a good, sensitive man who feels sorrow, frustration, and anger but manages to control his emotions. Jarvis makes us feel united with Bill as he fights murder charges and seeks to discover what really happened to the wife he loved. The murder victim's brother is given an irritating voice that suggests his untrustworthiness. This is a story about jealousy, greed , and guilt, and it's delivered by a skilled narrator who can stir our emotions and direct our perceptions. D.L.G. � AudioFile 2020, Portland, Maine