Pigtown

April 3, 1995
The gritty realism of Caunitz's new novel (after Cleopatra Gold), as in his earlier ones, reflects the more than two decades he spent with the NYPD. Caunitz's cops sound and act like the real thing, and his villains, while occasionally over the top, are fetchingly sinister (only the extravagant, mostly illicit sex here comes off as more fantasy than reportage). The murder of small-time hood Beansy Rutolo in the Brooklyn neighborhood dubbed ``Pigtown'' has a special significance for Lieutenant Matthew Stuart: the deceased's unexpected testimony once saved Matt's father from being kicked off the job for political reasons. Now the effort to track down Beansy's killers is revealing corruption that reaches deep into the Department-and goes back years. Matt is struggling with assorted personal demons too-the tragedy that ended his marriage; his secret relationship with a superior officer known as the ``Ice Maiden''; and an attempt to frame him for dereliction of duty. Caunitz's prose is flat-footed, weighed down with mundane detail, and his theme of ancient, festering corruption was old hat when Teddy Roosevelt was the city's police commissioner. Still, his feel for cops and cons matches anyone's, as evidenced once again by this flawed but still engaging novel, a police blotter come to life. Author tour.

The seemingly routine murder of a semi-retired mob soldier starts NYPD Detective Lt. Matt Stuart on a complex trail, which leads to the exposure of big-time drug trafficking and top-level police corruption. Reader David Colacci's ability to add emotion to his presentation of the many colorful characters expands listeners' feeling for the story and the people caught in the decades-old web of deceit. His comfortable, unforced delivery is right on the mark. Aside from the unnecessarily flowery final passage, this is a good book enhanced by an excellent audio production. T.J.M. (c)AudioFile, Portland, Maine