The Murder Stone

September 22, 2003
After six superb historicals (A Fearsome Doubt, etc.) featuring Inspector Rutledge, a man haunted by his WWI experiences, Todd misses the mark in his first stand-alone, a predictable, unengaging story of family secrets. Francesca Hatton, an unworldly young woman who's been volunteering for the Red Cross in London since the start of the Great War, returns in 1916 to her family home in the isolated Exe Valley, where her beloved grandfather, Francis Hatton, is on his death bed. After Francis dies, she finds that he kept many things from her, ranging from large properties he owned and maintained to his personal relationships. Her confusion is only compounded when a wounded ex-soldier, whose days are numbered, appears and accuses the older Hatton of having murdered his mother decades earlier. Despite her adoration of the man who reared her and her five orphaned male cousins, she begins to question her faith in him. Those doubts lead her to reexamine the mysterious deaths of her parents and numerous other relatives, though her sleuthing is little more sophisticated than that of Nancy Drew. Given the masterful way Todd's Rutledge novels capture the horrors of trench warfare and the brutal slaughter's effect on those returning to civilian life, it's all the more surprising that his portrayal of the war and its scars here is superficial. Todd's many admirers would be advised to give this a pass and wait for the next entry in the Rutledge series. (Nov. 4)FYI:Todd is the pseudonym of a mother-son writing team.

November 1, 2003
Todd's new standalone novel recounts the troubled life of Francesca Hatton. The loss of her five male cousins (all killed in World War I) and the recent death of her grandfather, Francis, have left her alone in the world. Wounded veteran Richard Leighton intrudes upon her grief by accusing Francis of being responsible for the mysterious disappearance many years earlier of Richard's mother, Victoria. Francesca begins to realize that Victoria's vanishing act is only one of countless secrets kept by her grandfather. Why did he own two other houses that she didn't know about? Why did he never speak about her dead parents? Why did his will require her to transport the large "murder stone" from the garden to remote Scotland? Fans of Todd's "Ian Rutledge" series (A Fearsome Doubt) will enjoy this book's many twists and turns, angst-ridden characters, and evocative historical setting. A gripping read.-Laurel Bliss, Princeton Univ. Lib., NJ

Copyright 2003 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.