Asking for Trouble

March 6, 2006
Criswell's latest novel is a sweet, standard family tale of trust, hard work and support in the small town of Mediocrity, Pa. Self-doubting divorcée Beth Randall is the new owner of a historic inn, Two Sisters Ordinary, bought from her eccentric live-in aunts, Ivy and Iris. Since the disappearance of Iris's fiancé Lyle McMurtry years ago, Ivy and Iris have garnered a reputation among town gossips as either witches or murderesses—depending on which gossip you talk to. When Beth finds buried bones in the inn's cellar, she can't bear to face the possibility that the gossips may be right, so she keeps mum. But when sexy Virginia pediatrician Brad Donovan, comes sniffing around, he casts further suspicion upon Beth, her aunts and the inn Beth has worked herself into colossal debt over. As much as Beth would like to dismiss Brad, he remains persistent—and none too hard on the eyes. Unfortunately, Criswell does not trust her leads to carry the novel, and the number of supporting characters and subplots she uses to fill it out make for a scattershot story, while awkward family-friendly language ("horse-doody," "running around like the proverbial chicken") dates the narrative. Though heartwarming, that slight virtue is not enough to make this familiar journey worthwhile.

April 1, 2006
The amazingly entertaining and consistently upbeat Criswell sets her latest romp in Mediocrity, Pennsylvania. The town has never been a major tourist stop, but Beth Randall is trying her best to make a success out of her inn, the Two Sisters Ordinary, named for her elderly aunts Iris and Ivy, who live on the fourth floor. They took care of Beth during her difficult childhood, and now it is Beth's turn to take care of them, only it appears that they may be involved with the disappearance of one of their guests. Dr. Brad Donovan and his teenage daughter Stacy come looking for Dr. Donovan's father, last seen at the inn, and Beth thinks her aunts are behaving awfully secretively. Brad is quite taken with the beautiful innkeeper, so Beth's aunts start playing matchmaker, unaware of Beth's suspicions. Criswell is always a fun read, and her latest contemporary romance has great small-town appeal and lots of quirky characters.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2006, American Library Association.)