She Is the Darkness

July 31, 1997
Although an intelligent fantasy, this second volume of Cook's Glittering Stone trilogy (after Bleak Seasons) will be tough going for those unfamiliar with the preceding tales about the mercenary Black Company (of which this is the seventh). In it, narrator Murgen--annalist, narrator, ghostwalker--discovers that his wife and newborn son are alive. Meanwhile, an impressive host of demigods, demons, sorcerers, assassins and unclassifiable entities led by the goddess Kina (Kali in disguise) and by Soulcatcher--sister to Lady, the wife of Croaker, the commander of the Black Company--array themselves against the Company. At the cliffhanger ending, Croaker is led into folly that threatens the Company's existence. Cook deserves high marks for much in this novel, including the gritty realism of the soldiers' dialogue and of the attitude of the civilians (who seem to suffer much like the Vietnamese did during the Vietnam War) toward the warriors rampaging over their towns and fields. The distinctively non-Western flavor of much of the mythology is also welcome. Large parts of the book read like a collaboration between Michael Moorcock and the late John Masters, dean of historical novels of the British Raj. Indeed, the book offers virtually anything a fantasy reader could ask for, except a coherent narrative that stands on its own.

September 15, 1997
The latest of Cook's chronicles of the Black Company follows the events of "Bleak Seasons" (1996) directly. The company's battle against Soulcatcher, the goddess Kina, and their various human, demihuman, and demonic allies progresses bloodily. While "ghostwalking," Murgen the annalist and narrator discovers that his wife is still alive; the shadows take a more active part in the fighting; and at the end, Croaker the "Old Man" is tempted into a betrayal that threatens the existence of the company and concludes the volume on a cliff-hanging note. Wrenchingly realistic in both the details of war and the emotions of the characters and drawing eclectically but intelligently on dozens of different elements, the book still doesn't constitute a smooth narrative, simply because there are, after six preceding Black Company yarns, so many characters and elements that only devout followers of the saga possess the knowledge to make full sense of it. But those followers are numerous. ((Reviewed September 15, 1997))(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 1997, American Library Association.)