Comanche Moon

July 1, 1997
If you've ever wondered what happened between Dead Man's Walk and Lonesome Dove, here's your chance to find out.

September 15, 1997
At the conclusion of McMurtry's epic masterpiece, "Lonesome Dove," Ranger Woodrow Call is haunted by the human cost of his determination to drive cattle to Montana. "A hell of a vision," he sarcastically comments to a reporter. For McMurtry, the experience of the Hat Creek Cattle Company served as a metaphor for much of the frontier experience; it was heroic, ennobling of spirit, but, in the end, heartbreaking. "Comanche Moon" is the fourth of the Ranger series and the second prequel to "Lonesome Dove." Here, as Texas anticipates the outbreak of the Civil War, Gus McRae and Woodrow Call are relatively young men. Their rangering activities are primarily directed at subduing the declining but still deadly Comanches. In this panorama of antebellum Texas, McMurtry reintroduces familiar characters, some fiction, some historical, some endearing, and some terrifying, including Deets, the black scout; Clara, the longtime love of Gus McRae; Buffalo Hump, the fierce, primitive Comanche warrior; and Buffalo Hump's sociopathic son, Blue Duck. McMurtry's depiction of the West is far removed from the dime-novel portrayal of constant excitement and adventure. Instead, white settlers, rangers, and Comanches endure long periods of grinding tedium, punctuated by spasms of deadly violence, which often arrive with seemingly silent inevitability. As usual, McMurtry's narrative unfolds slowly, as the reader is gradually introduced to time, place, and people; yet the plot is consistently engrossing, and McMurtry's revisionist vision of frontier life is always compelling. ((Reviewed September 15, 1997))(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 1997, American Library Association.)